Wine Rankings

All 15 wines ranked by aggregated critic scores. Filter, sort, and find your perfect bottle.

All TypesDessertFortifiedRedRoséSparklingWhite
ScorePrice (Low)Price (High)Name
Seneca Lake x
15 wines foundPage 1 of 1
1

Dry Riesling

Hermann J. Wiemer

Seneca Lake, United States · Riesling

75.4
⭐VinePair 50 Best #11 (2024)
White
2

Reserve Dry Riesling

Hermann J. Wiemer

Seneca Lake, United States · Riesling

73.5
White
3

Chardonnay

Hermann J. Wiemer

Seneca Lake, United States · Chardonnay

71.7
White
4

Classique Dry Riesling

Forge Cellars

Seneca Lake, United States · Riesling

70.1
White
5

Railroad Dry Riesling

Forge Cellars

Seneca Lake, United States · Riesling

68.8
⭐VinePair 50 Best #35 (2024)
White
6

Cuvée Brut

Hermann J. Wiemer

Seneca Lake, United States · Chardonnay

68.7
Sparkling
7

Peach Orchard Dry Riesling

Forge Cellars

Seneca Lake, United States · Riesling

68.2
White
8

Dry Riesling

Silver Thread

Seneca Lake, United States · Riesling

67.7
White
9

Dry Riesling

Belhurst

Seneca Lake, United States · Riesling

67.6
White
10

Breakneck Creek Dry Riesling

Forge Cellars

Seneca Lake, United States · Riesling

67.6
White
11

DeChaunac

J.R. Dill

Seneca Lake, United States · De Chaunac

65.7
Red
12

Vidal Blanc

Atwater Estate

Seneca Lake, United States · Vidal Blanc

65.6
White
13

Cabernet Sauvignon

Chateau LaFayette Reneau

Seneca Lake, United States · Cabernet Sauvignon

64.8
Red
14

Dry Riesling

Atwater Estate

Seneca Lake, United States · Riesling

64.4
White
15

Don Giovanni Cabernet Franc

Silver Springs

Seneca Lake, United States · Cabernet Franc

64.3
Red