Wine Rankings

All 61 wines ranked by aggregated critic scores. Filter, sort, and find your perfect bottle.

All TypesDessertFortifiedRedRos茅SparklingWhite
ScorePrice (Low)Price (High)Name
Santa Maria Valley x
61 wines foundPage 1 of 2
1

Bien Nacido Vineyards Pinot Noir

Stephen Ross

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Pinot Noir

68
Red
2

Chardonnay

Whitcraft

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Chardonnay

68
White
3

Syrah

Element

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Syrah/Shiraz

67.8
Red
4

Bien Nacido Vineyard Grand Reserve Chardonnay

Villa Mt. Eden

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Chardonnay

67.7
White
5

Borgo Buon Natale Tocai Friulano

Clendenen

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Friulano/Sauvignonasse

67.6
White
6

Bien Nacido Vineyard Block N Pinot Noir

Longoria

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Pinot Noir

67.4
Red
7

Chardonnay Clone 4

Cambria

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Chardonnay

67.2
White
8

Bien Nacido Cuv茅e

Qup茅

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Viognier

67.2
White
9

Sierra Maore Vineyard Pinot Noir

Whitcraft

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Pinot Noir

67.1
Red
10

Chardonnay Rae's Vineyard

Cambria

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Chardonnay

66.9
White
11

Chardonnay Nuits-Blanches au Bouge XXth Anniversary

Au Bon Climat

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Chardonnay

66.6
White
12

Rorick Heritage Vineyard Mondeuse Ros茅

Jaimee Motley

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Mondeuse Noire

65.8
Ros茅
13

Chardonnay Clone 96

Cambria

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Chardonnay

65.7
White
14

Bien Nacido Vineyard Pinot Noir

Whitcraft

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Pinot Noir

65.7
Red
15

Chardonnay Unwooded

Cambria

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Chardonnay

65.2
White
16

Pinot Noir Santa Maria Valley

Au Bon Climat

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Pinot Noir

72.8
Red
17

Syrah Tepusquet Vineyard

Cambria

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Syrah/Shiraz

72.4
Red
18

Santa Maria Pinot Noir

Row Eleven

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Pinot Noir

71.5
Red
19

Dierberg Vineyard Pinot Noir

Flying Goat

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Pinot Noir

71.3
Red
20

Chardonnay

Ojai

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Chardonnay

71.3
White
21

Solomon Hills Vineyard Pinot Noir

Rusack

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Pinot Noir

71.1
Red
22

Roussanne Bien Nacido Hillside Estate

Qup茅

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Roussanne

71
White
23

Pinot Noir

J. Wilkes

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Pinot Noir

70.9
Red
24

Chardonnay

Dierberg

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Chardonnay

70.8
White
25

Viognier Tepusquet Vineyard

Cambria

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Viognier

70.5
White
26

Pinot Noir Julia's Vineyard

Cambria

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Pinot Noir

70.5
Red
27

Pinot Noir Clone 115

Cambria

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Pinot Noir

70
Red
28

Chardonnay Katherine's Vineyard

Cambria

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Chardonnay

70
White
29

Pinot Noir Bench Break Vineyard

Cambria

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Pinot Noir

69.7
Red
30

Homage Collection Pinot Blanc

Zaca Mesa

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Pinot Blanc

69.5
White
31

Vintners Select Pinot Noir

Summerland

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Pinot Noir

69.4
Red
32

Swan Clone Pinot Noir

Byron

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Pinot Noir

66.3
Red
33

Garey Ranch Vineyard Pinot Noir

Kenneth Volk

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Pinot Noir

66.3
Red
34

Santa Maria Valley Chardonnay

Nielson

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Chardonnay

64.8
White
35

Katherine's Vineyard Signature Collection Chardonnay

Cambria

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Chardonnay

64.5
White
36

Santa Maria Cuv茅e Chardonnay

Kenneth Volk

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Chardonnay

62.5
White
37

Belle Glos Clark & Telephone Vineyard Pinot Noir 2021

Belle Glos

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Pinot Noir

84.7
Red
38

Pinot Noir Knox Alexander

Au Bon Climat

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Pinot Noir

79.4
Red
39

Hildegard

Au Bon Climat

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Pinot Gris

78.9
White
40

Santa Maria Valley Pinot Noir

B枚en

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Pinot Noir

78.6
Red
41

Highland Estates Camelot Highlands Chardonnay

Kendall-Jackson

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Chardonnay

78.3
White
42

Pinot Noir

Bien Nacido Vineyards

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Pinot Noir

76
Red
43

Pinot Noir

Dierberg

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Pinot Noir

75.5
Red
44

Bien Nacido Historic Vineyards Chardonnay

Au Bon Climat

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Chardonnay

74.9
White
45

True Believer

Hammell

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Syrah/Shiraz

74.6
Red
46

Pinot Noir La Bauge Au-Dessus

Au Bon Climat

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Pinot Noir

73.9
Red
47

Pinot Noir Barbara's Clone 667

Cambria

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Pinot Noir

73.8
Red
48

Pinot Noir Clone 4

Cambria

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Pinot Noir

73.3
Red
49

Chardonnay

Kenneth Volk

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Chardonnay

63.9
White
50

Pinot Gris Tepusquet Vineyard

Cambria

Santa Maria Valley, United States 路 Pinot Gris

63
White
12Next