Wine Rankings

All 86 wines ranked by aggregated critic scores. Filter, sort, and find your perfect bottle.

All TypesDessertFortifiedRedRoséSparklingWhite
ScorePrice (Low)Price (High)Name
Hunter Valley x
86 wines foundPage 1 of 2
1

Cabernets

Lake's Folly

Hunter Valley, Australia · Cabernet Sauvignon

81.7
Red
2

Graveyard Vineyard Shiraz

Brokenwood

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

81.7
⭐Halliday Wine Companion #2 (2025)
Red
3

Maurice o'Shea Shiraz

Mount Pleasant

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

79
Red
4

The Kester Shiraz

Keith Tulloch

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

76.8
Red
5

Vat 9 Shiraz

Tyrrell's

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

76.8
Red
6

Hector of Glen Elgin Limited Release Shiraz

Tulloch

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

76.1
Red
7

3 Estates

Lake's Folly

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

75.9
Red
8

Mistress Block Vineyard Shiraz

Brokenwood

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

75.2
Red
9

Vat 8 Shiraz-Cabernet

Tyrrell's

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

74.9
Red
10

Brokenwood Graveyard Vineyard Shiraz 2004

Brokenwood

Hunter Valley, Australia · Shiraz/Syrah

74.1
Red
11

Old Paddock & Old Hill Shiraz

Mount Pleasant

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

73.5
⭐Tyson Stelzer Top 250 (2024)
Red
12

Alexander Munro Shiraz

Meerea Park

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

73.1
Red
13

Red Blend

Lake's Folly

Hunter Valley, Australia · Cabernet Sauvignon

72.4
Red
14

Brokenwood Shiraz 2004

Brokenwood

Hunter Valley, Australia · Shiraz/Syrah

72.3
Red
15

Reserve Syrah

Tamburlaine

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

72.1
Red
16

HBA Shiraz

Brokenwood

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

71.9
Red
17

Single Vineyard Coquun Shiraz

Pepper Tree

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

71.8
Red
18

Verona Vineyard Shiraz

Brokenwood

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

70.8
Red
19

Chambourcin

Ivanhoe

Hunter Valley, Australia · Chambourcin

70.8
Red
20

Shiraz

Brokenwood

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

70.5
Red
21

Rosehill Shiraz

Mount Pleasant

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

70.3
Red
22

Smoking Barrel Red

Gundog

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

70.1
Red
23

Rufus Stone Heathcote Shiraz

Tyrrell's

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

70.1
Red
24

The Redgiment Selected Release Shiraz

Tatler

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

70
Red
25

Diedrich Shiraz

Gartelmann

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

69.8
Red
26

Sheila Black Sheep Shiraz

Moorebank Vineyard

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

69.4
Red
27

Quail Shiraz

Brokenwood

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

69.2
Red
28

Chambourcin

Calais

Hunter Valley, Australia · Chambourcin

69.2
Red
29

Shiraz-Viognier

Keith Tulloch

Hunter Valley, Australia · Viognier

69.2
Red
30

Cellar Select Summer Shiraz

McGuigan

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

69.1
Red
31

Chambourcin

Domaine de Binet

Hunter Valley, Australia · Chambourcin

68.7
Red
32

The Ripper Shiraz

Hope Estate

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

68.4
Red
33

Virgin Hills Vineyard Shiraz-Malbec

Hope Estate

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

67.8
Red
34

NVC Shiraz

Tyrrell's

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

67.8
Red
35

Premium Boutique Shiraz-Malbec

Ivanhoe

Hunter Valley, Australia · Malbec

67.8
Red
36

Black Label Shiraz

McGuigan

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

67.4
Red
37

Phillip Alexander Cabernet-Merlot

Gartelmann

Hunter Valley, Australia · Cabernet Franc

67.4
Red
38

James Cabernet-Merlot

Tintilla

Hunter Valley, Australia · Cabernet Sauvignon

67.3
Red
39

Sweet Chambourcin

Stonehurst

Hunter Valley, Australia · Chambourcin

67.2
Red
40

Hahn Single Vineyard Shiraz-Mataro

Tyrrell's

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

67.2
Red
41

Signature Shiraz

Bimbadgen

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

67
Red
42

Bin 6600 Shiraz

Lindeman's

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

67
Red
43

Chambourcin

Stonehurst

Hunter Valley, Australia · Chambourcin

66.8
Red
44

Reserve Chambourcin

Tamburlaine

Hunter Valley, Australia · Chambourcin

66.7
Red
45

Cabernet Sauvignon-Shiraz

Brokenwood

Hunter Valley, Australia · Cabernet Sauvignon

66.7
Red
46

Macedon Ranges Malbec

Tower Estate

Hunter Valley, Australia · Malbec

66.7
Red
47

Reserve Shiraz

McGuigan

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

66.6
Red
48

Cabernet Sauvignon-Shiraz

Oakvale

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

66.5
Red
49

Catherine de ‘M Sangiovese-Merlot

Tintilla

Hunter Valley, Australia · Merlot

66.5
Red
50

Shiraz

Hope Estate

Hunter Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

66.4
Red
12Next