Wine Rankings

All 177 wines ranked by aggregated critic scores. Filter, sort, and find your perfect bottle.

All TypesDessertFortifiedRedRoséSparklingWhite
ScorePrice (Low)Price (High)Name
Clare Valley x
177 wines foundPage 1 of 4
1

The Benbournie Cabernet Sauvignon

Jim Barry

Clare Valley, Australia · Cabernet Sauvignon

77.4
Red
2

Polish Hill Riesling

Grosset

Clare Valley, Australia · Riesling

76.8
⭐Tyson Stelzer Top 250 (2024)
White
3

First Eleven Cabernet Sauvignon

Jim Barry

Clare Valley, Australia · Cabernet Sauvignon

76.4
Red
4

Kilikanoon Oracle Shiraz 2005

Kilikanoon

Clare Valley, Australia · Shiraz/Syrah

76.4
Red
5

Attunga 1865 Shiraz

Kilikanoon

Clare Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

76.2
Red
6

Br. John May Reserve Release Shiraz

Sevenhill

Clare Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

75.9
Red
7

Covenant Shiraz

Kilikanoon

Clare Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

75.7
Red
8

Gaia

Grosset

Clare Valley, Australia · Cabernet Sauvignon

75.4
Red
9

The Pioneer Shiraz

Taylors/Wakefield

Clare Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

75.3
Red
10

Cordon Cut

Mount Horrocks

Clare Valley, Australia · Riesling

74.9
Dessert
11

Kilikanoon Prodigal Grenache 2003

Kilikanoon

Clare Valley, Australia · Grenache

74.7
Red
12

Dark Side of The Moon Shiraz

Claymore Wines

Clare Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

74.3
Red
13

Basket Pressed Shiraz

Skillogalee

Clare Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

73.8
Red
14

McNicol Shiraz

Mitchell

Clare Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

73.6
Red
15

Duke Reserve Grenache

Kilikanoon

Clare Valley, Australia · Grenache

73.5
Red
16

The Florita Riesling

Jim Barry

Clare Valley, Australia · Riesling

73.5
White
17

Nírva'na Reserve Shiraz

Claymore Wines

Clare Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

73.2
Red
18

Prodigal Grenache

Kilikanoon

Clare Valley, Australia · Grenache

73.2
Red
19

Claire Reserve Shiraz

O'Leary Walker

Clare Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

73.1
Red
20

St Ignatius Red

Sevenhill

Clare Valley, Australia · Cabernet Sauvignon

72.9
Red
21

Pb Shiraz-Cabernet Sauvignon

Jim Barry

Clare Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

72.7
Red
22

McNicol Riesling

Mitchell

Clare Valley, Australia · Riesling

72.5
White
23

Blocks Road Cabernet Sauvignon

Kilikanoon

Clare Valley, Australia · Cabernet Sauvignon

72.3
Red
24

Kilikanoon Blocks Road Cabernet Sauvignon 2002

Kilikanoon

Clare Valley, Australia · Cabernet Sauvignon

72.2
Red
25

Yellow Label Hanlin Hill Riesling

Petaluma

Clare Valley, Australia · Riesling

72.2
White
26

Special Release Cabernet Sauvignon Reserve Parcel

Taylors/Wakefield

Clare Valley, Australia · Cabernet Sauvignon

72.1
Red
27

Shiraz

Tim Adams

Clare Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

72
Red
28

Springvale Riesling

Grosset

Clare Valley, Australia · Riesling

71.9
White
29

Basket Pressed The Cabernets

Skillogalee

Clare Valley, Australia · Cabernet Sauvignon

71.8
Red
30

The Assemblage

Pikes

Clare Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

67.9
Red
31

Watervale Riesling

Mount Horrocks

Clare Valley, Australia · Riesling

67.9
White
32

St Clare Single Vineyard Shiraz

Reillys

Clare Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

67.9
Red
33

Inigo Cabernet Sauvignon

Sevenhill

Clare Valley, Australia · Cabernet Sauvignon

67.8
Red
34

Naked On Roller Skates

Some Young Punks

Clare Valley, Australia · Mataro

67.7
Red
35

Sparkling Peppertree

Mitchell

Clare Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

67.5
Sparkling
36

The First Riesling

Naked Run

Clare Valley, Australia · Riesling

67.4
White
37

The Lodge Hill Shiraz

Jim Barry

Clare Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

67.4
Red
38

Cabernet-Malbec Rosé

Skillogalee

Clare Valley, Australia · Malbec

64.2
Rosé
39

Promised Land Unwooded Chardonnay

Taylors/Wakefield

Clare Valley, Australia · Chardonnay

64.1
White
40

Estate Pinot Gris

Taylors/Wakefield

Clare Valley, Australia · Pinot Gris

64
White
41

Cabernet Sauvignon

Kirrihill

Clare Valley, Australia · Cabernet Sauvignon

63.9
Red
42

No. 52 Shiraz

Cleanskin

Clare Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

63.9
Red
43

The Ringmaster Riesling

Koonowla

Clare Valley, Australia · Riesling

63.9
White
44

Cabernet Sauvignon

Starve Dog Lane

Clare Valley, Australia · Cabernet Sauvignon

63.9
Red
45

Clare Red Shiraz-Cab

Jim Barry

Clare Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

63.9
Red
46

Shiraz

Annie's Lane

Clare Valley, Australia · Syrah/Shiraz

63.4
Red
47

Lavender Hill Off-Dry Riesling

Jim Barry

Clare Valley, Australia · Riesling

63.3
White
48

Barking Mad Watervale Riesling

Reillys

Clare Valley, Australia · Riesling

63
White
49

DJW Riesling

The Wilson Vineyard

Clare Valley, Australia · Riesling

63
White
50

Promised Land Cabernet-Merlot

Taylors/Wakefield

Clare Valley, Australia · Cabernet Sauvignon

62.9
Red
1234Next