Wine Rankings

All 120 wines ranked by aggregated critic scores. Filter, sort, and find your perfect bottle.

All TypesDessertFortifiedRedRoséSparklingWhite
ScorePrice (Low)Price (High)Name
Calistoga x
120 wines foundPage 1 of 3
1

Cabernet Sauvignon Bone Ash Vineyard

Venge Vineyards

Calistoga, United States · Cabernet Sauvignon

88.4
Red
2

Volcanic Hill Cabernet Sauvignon

Diamond Creek

Calistoga, United States · Cabernet Sauvignon

88.4
Red
3

The Montelena Estate Cabernet Sauvignon

Chateau Montelena

Calistoga, United States · Cabernet Sauvignon

88.2
Red
4

Il Barone

Castello di Amorosa

Calistoga, United States · Cabernet Sauvignon

87.8
Red
5

La Castellana

Castello di Amorosa

Calistoga, United States · Cabernet Sauvignon

85.6
Red
6

Blueline Estate Cabernet Sauvignon

Hourglass

Calistoga, United States · Cabernet Sauvignon

83.9
Red
7

La Fantasia Frizzante Rosé

Castello di Amorosa

Calistoga, United States · Syrah/Shiraz

81.9
Sparkling
8

Cabernet Sauvignon

Jones

Calistoga, United States · Cabernet Sauvignon

81.9
Red
9

Kenefick Ranch Cabernet Sauvignon

Nickel & Nickel

Calistoga, United States · Cabernet Sauvignon

80.1
Red
10

Sweet Berry Wine

Las Jaras Wines

Calistoga, United States · Carignan/Cariñena

80
⭐VinePair 50 Best #2 (2024)
Red
11

Zingaro Old Vine Zinfandel

Castello di Amorosa

Calistoga, United States · Zinfandel

79.4
Red
12

Amoenus Cabernet Sauvignon

Maybach Family Vineyards

Calistoga, United States · Cabernet Sauvignon

79.3
Red
13

Cabernet Sauvignon

JAX Vineyards

Calistoga, United States · Cabernet Sauvignon

77.7
Red
14

Treva's Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon

Harris Estate Vineyards

Calistoga, United States · Cabernet Sauvignon

77.1
Red
15

Casey’s Lakeview Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon

Harris Estate Vineyards

Calistoga, United States · Cabernet Sauvignon

76.9
Red
16

Parr Vineyard Chardonnay

Maldonado

Calistoga, United States · Chardonnay

76.3
White
17

Il Brigante

Castello di Amorosa

Calistoga, United States · Petit Verdot

76.3
Red
18

Art Bus Red

La Sirena

Calistoga, United States · Cabernet Franc

76.3
Red
19

Zinfandel

Chateau Montelena

Calistoga, United States · Zinfandel

76.3
Red
20

Gewürztraminer

Castello di Amorosa

Calistoga, United States · Gewürztraminer

75.5
White
21

Bien Nacido Vineyards Reserve Chardonnay

Castello di Amorosa

Calistoga, United States · Chardonnay

75
White
22

Cabernet Sauvignon

Shypoke

Calistoga, United States · Cabernet Sauvignon

74.6
Red
23

Antaeus

Storybook Mountain

Calistoga, United States · Cabernet Sauvignon

74.5
Red
24

Syrah Santa Ynez Valley

La Sirena

Calistoga, United States · Syrah/Shiraz

74.5
⭐VinePair 50 Best #5 (2024)
Red
25

Méthode Champenois Rouge

Frank Family

Calistoga, United States · Chardonnay

73.9
Sparkling
26

Peter Newton Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon

Maldonado

Calistoga, United States · Cabernet Sauvignon

73.3
Red
27

Maritime Vineyard Pinot Noir

W.H. Smith

Calistoga, United States · Pinot Noir

73.3
Red
28

Vermentino

Castello di Amorosa

Calistoga, United States · Vermentino

71.5
White
29

Las Viñas del Señor Cabernet Sauvignon

Madrigal

Calistoga, United States · Cabernet Sauvignon

71.4
Red
30

Zinfandel

Madrigal

Calistoga, United States · Zinfandel

71.4
Red
31

Pinot Bianco

Castello di Amorosa

Calistoga, United States · Pinot Blanc

71.2
White
32

Villa Andriana Vineyard Zinfandel

Summers

Calistoga, United States · Zinfandel

71.1
Red
33

Hommage Chardonnay

Clos Pegase

Calistoga, United States · Chardonnay

70.8
White
34

Estate Reserve Syrah

Chafen Family Vineyards

Calistoga, United States · Syrah/Shiraz

70.4
Red
35

Oat Hill Estate Zinfandel

Laura Michael Wines-Zahtila Vineyards

Calistoga, United States · Zinfandel

70.3
Red
36

Estate Cuvée

Clos Pegase

Calistoga, United States · Cabernet Franc

70.1
Red
37

Vintner's Collection Dark Red Blend

Sterling Vineyards

Calistoga, United States · Merlot

70.1
Red
38

Sauvignon Blanc

Kelly Fleming

Calistoga, United States · Sauvignon Blanc

70
White
39

Cabernet Sauvignon

Summers

Calistoga, United States · Cabernet Sauvignon

69.7
Red
40

Julie's Creekside Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon

Harris Estate Vineyards

Calistoga, United States · Cabernet Sauvignon

69.5
Red
41

Hellenthal Vineyard Pinot Noir

W.H. Smith

Calistoga, United States · Pinot Noir

69.5
Red
42

Vineyards Sparkling Rose

Sterling Vineyards

Calistoga, United States · Chardonnay

69.5
Sparkling
43

Marimar Estate Vineyard Pinot Noir

W.H. Smith

Calistoga, United States · Pinot Noir

69.5
Red
44

Spumante del Castello Brut

Castello di Amorosa

Calistoga, United States · Chardonnay

69.5
Sparkling
45

Rosé

Las Jaras Wines

Calistoga, United States · Carignan/Cariñena

69.2
Rosé
46

The Pioneer's Journey Cabernet Sauvignon

Sterling Vineyards

Calistoga, United States · Cabernet Sauvignon

68.6
Red
47

Cellar Club Zinfandel

Sterling Vineyards

Calistoga, United States · Zinfandel

68.4
Red
48

Forcini Vineyard Zinfandel

Once & Future

Calistoga, United States · Zinfandel

68.1
Red
49

Reserve Fumé Blanc

Madrigal

Calistoga, United States · Fumé Blanc

68.1
White
50

Petite Sirah

Summers

Calistoga, United States · Petite Sirah

67.9
Red
123Next